What Do The Manufactured Home Community Market Experts Think?
Author: Bruce Nell Category: Commercial Real Estate News, Manufactured Home Community, PGP Valuation Inc
Email Post
Print Post
How have the Capital markets affected lending for the manufactured home community industry?
The significant turmoil in the real estate capital markets has resulted in a considerable vacuum in financing opportunities for Manufactured Home Communities. Once a favorite of the now inactive CMBS/Conduit loan industry, the MHC asset class has become increasingly reliant on Fannie Mae, life insurance company, and commercial bank loan executions. Many MHC and RV Resort operators, in addition to borrowers across every asset class, had found favor in recent years with aggressive Conduit lending programs and their high loan-to-value and low debt service coverage thresholds. With the disappearance of this segment of the capital marketplace, the availability of competitively priced, non-recourse first lien financing for MHC’s outside of Fannie Mae does exist, however with comparatively less attractive terms.
Portfolio life insurance companies are still in the market and are providing non-recourse financing, however their fixed rates range from 7% to 8%, which is 1.5% to 2.0% higher than Fannie Mae fixed rates today. Commercial banks will loan up to 75% loan-to-value on MHC’s, subject to debt coverage requirements of 1.25x typically. The best bank pricing today is in the low to mid 6% range, and the borrower must sign a personal guarantee. The bright spot for MHC financing continues to be Fannie Mae, but they too are getting tighter in their underwriting and pricing. The highlight of Fannie Mae’s offerings today includes a variable rate loan program with fully indexed rates in the high 4% range and a lifetime cap between 6.75% and 7.25%.
Zachary E. Koucos
Associate Director HFF
858.812.2351 Office
858.552.7695 Fax
Securitized lending for individual properties (CMBS or conduit loans) emerged in the mid-1990s as a very popular lending option for commercial real estate including MHCs. Conduit lending was embraced by lenders as a way to generate lending profits while shifting the risk of defaults to bondholders who purchased the bonds that were collateralized by the individual loans. In some years conduit lending accounted for up to 60 percent of annual commercial lending volume. Borrowers benefited by having very attractive (interest rates and leverage) non-recourse financing available for most properties including MHCs, which had previously been viewed by many lenders as a special purpose asset. The existence of conduits also resulted in better terms being available from non-conduit or traditional balance sheet lenders as they had to compete with conduits to obtain business. However, the recent capital market turmoil brought the origination of conduit loans to a halt as the buyers of these bonds, or CMBS, exited the market. With conduit lenders gone from the market, many MHC borrowers with existing conduit loans are facing challenges in refinancing their properties.
Tony Petosa
Senior Vice President
Wells Fargo Multifamily Capital
760.438.2153 Office
760.505.9001 Cell
760.438.8710 Fax
To use a Vegas analogy, we went from a “hot” craps table where everybody is winning, to the desperation of placing your last dollar into the slot machine on the way out, hoping you’ll get lucky. OK, maybe not that extreme, but close. Over the past several years, there were many options to finance your MHC; you had the CMBS/conduit lenders, the life companies, GE, commercial banks and the Fannie Mae DUS lenders, to name a few, and they all wanted a piece of the action.
Due to MHCs being a proven asset class within the finance world (high performing loans and low delinquencies), they were viewed as favorably as a Class A apartment complex in a strong Southern California market. At the peak, it was common to see 10 years interest only, 80%+ leverage and a sub-100 spread on any given community. Then, much like the economy as a whole, the bottom fell out and we went from an extremely liquid and aggressive market to a cautious, selective, downright tough market.
The good news is that we are still closing loans under the Fannie Mae DUS program. Although the terms are not quite as attractive, it is still possible, and realistic, to get a non-recourse, less than 6% fixed rate loan with a 10 year term and a 25 to 30 year amortization schedule at 75% leverage on high quality communities. Other than that, you may be able to find a local bank or a life company to consider something on a recourse basis and/or a more conservative structure.
Todd Elkins
Vice President
Grandbridge Real Estate Capital LLC
205.978.1920 Office
205.978.1852 Fax
With the capital market providers still on the sidelines , owners of manufactured home communities basically have two choices when it comes to financing – Fannie Mae and everything else. I divide it into two choices since Fannie Mae is the best option in the market today and Capmark is actively closing loans through its Fannie Mae platform. The main issue is having the community qualify for a Fannie Mae loan from the quality standpoint. The community generally has to be 3.5 star quality and higher, 50% of the spaces have to accommodate multi-sectional homes, very little park owned homes, 5% or less RV sites, good amenity package and has to show well. Current underwriting guidelines are 80% LTV with a 1.25x debt coverage ratio with terms ranging from 5 to 30 years. Amortization schedule of 25 to 30 years. Keep in mind that Fannie Mae has been tightening their underwriting requirements, so a deal that fit the program a year ago may not qualify today.
If the community doesn’t qualify for Fannie Mae, then it falls into what I call “everything else”, meaning Capmark works with the borrower to try and find a loan. There are several smaller banks that will lend on manufactured home communities throughout the country. The underwriting is going to be more conservative than Fannie Mae, generally LTV of 60 – 70% with 1.30 + debt coverage ratio. The terms are going to be shorter as is the amortization. Capmark also works with life insurance companies to fund loans for manufactured home communities. Some insurance companies will lend on communities that don’t qualify for Fannie Mae program ; it really comes down to deal specifics.
As a community owner who needs financing in this challenging environment, it is important to allow more time to get your loan closed and it is very important to work with lenders that know what they are doing.
Damon B. Reed
Vice President Capmark Finance Inc
205.991.6700, Ext 8191
205.991.9101 Fax
205.601.2855 Cell
Underwriting parameters continue to become more conservative. Fannie Mae recently announced that all-age communities (non-age restricted) will need to utilize a 25 year amortization, as opposed to the standard 30-year amortization. Fannie is taking a harder look at asset quality and only wants to lend on the highest quality communities. That being said, Fannie Mae closed on over $1 billion in manufactured housing business in 2008, which was a huge jump from the previous year. Rates are still very attractive for communities that do qualify, with 10-year loans currently pricing in the 5.75-6.25% range. With limited other financing options, we expect to continue to see a large volume of manufactured housing owners seeking Fannie Mae financing in 2009 for their communities.
Andrew Tapley
Senior Vice President Multifamily Finance
301.215.5578 Office
301.634.2151 Fax
In the next 12 to 24 months do you foresee any new financing sources or options that are not currently available for MHC owners?
I have been lending on manufactured home communities since 1995 and it’s hard for me to imagine that the capital market providers will stay on the sidelines forever. I think we are several months away before any of the Wall Street firms dip their toe in the securitization market. I do think by 2010, we will see some “conduit’ lending for manufactured home communities, albeit on much more conservative terms that what was done in 2007. Manufactured home communities as an asset class are holding up well compared to other commercial property types. If that trend continues, you may have more life insurance companies and even pension funds start to lend on communities. Overall, I am optimistic that the worse days are behind us and that we may start to see “normal” lending emerge in the near future.
Damon B. Reed
Vice President Capmark Finance Inc.
205.991.6700, Ext 8191
205.991.9101 Fax
205.601.2855 Cell
Yes, we are seeing the marketplace gradually deepen for MHC financing as more lenders have taken note that Manufactured Home Communities as an asset class provide a reliable, low-risk investment. Life insurance companies as well as commercial and regional banks that historically have not transacted in the MHC sector are beginning to realize the inherent value of including this product type in their investment portfolios. The word is out – low loan delinquency ratios, high occupancy rates, and consistent cash flow make MHC’s one of the most attractive options for the deployment of capital in these uncertain times.
We are also seeing many public and private capital sources raising debt and equity funds for the origination of first lien, mezzanine, bridge, and structured finance transactions. More and more of these capital sources have MHC’s on their list of preferred product types. The ability to navigate the capital landscape left standing after the implosion of the MBS/Conduit marketplace is crucial today for MHC operators who are finding that their go-to lenders are no longer active or existent. The good news is that there will be capital available and looking for opportunities, albeit with a tighter strike zone on underwriting, pricing, and terms.
Zachary E. Koucos
Associate Director HFF
858.812.2351 Office
858.552.7695 Fax
For the near future, we see Fannie Mae as the best financing source for MHCs. Fannie Mae offers long-term fixed rate, non-recourse financing to qualified MHC’s (10-year fixed rates are currently under 6%), and this has helped fill the some of the void left by the conduit market. For properties that do not qualify for Fannie Mae financing, portfolio lending programs would be the next option. Borrowers will find, however, that portfolio lending programs often require full recourse (personal guarantees) and the terms and rates are not as attractive as what can be found with Fannie Mae currently. Beyond that, seller financing may be an option if a borrower is acquiring a property. In that instance, the financing terms will be the result of what the buyer is able to negotiate with the seller. Will conduit lending return? Ultimately we believe it will, but not for the foreseeable future and likely in a more regulated environment with tighter credit standards.
Nick Bertino
Vice President Wells Fargo Multifamily Capital
760.438.2629 Office
858.336.0782 Cell
760.438.8710 Fax
With the single-family market struggling, how do you think this will affect the manufactured home community industry?
Simply put, the struggling single family market presents terrific challenges and great potential. The potential is to design creative and sustaining programs that enable companies like ours to provide quality, affordable shelter to families who have challenging balance sheets and credit histories because they are moving from housing they can’t afford to factory-built homes in community neighborhoods that present a lifestyle and a value proposition that they can embrace. The real challenge for our company is developing programs to take advantage of the baby-boomer population wanting to downsize, but not being able to sell and capture their perceived equity in the current home they have occupied for decades.
James A. Reitzner
President & Director Asset Development Group, Inc
414.507.8057
jim.reitzner@assetdevelopment.com
In the near term, on the 55+ side, the inability of our prospects to sell their homes has been affecting us for a while now. New home sales in age restricted communities have dramatically slowed given the difficulties these prospective residents face in selling their permanent homes. When houses do start to sell, and there is evidence the inventory of foreclosures and short sales is starting to move in the Sunbelt states, we’re going to be competing with some relatively cheap stick-built product. I think this will force us to revisit the floor plans and models we’re spec’ing. For a while, when the market was hot, the homes we were selling kept getting bigger and more expensive (triples, two-car garages, granite and stainless steel, etc.). This worked because the cost of alternative housing was increasing so rapidly and our customers were pulling out large amounts of equity from their homes in the north. That is obviously not the case at this point and we are going to be selling in a much more “normal” market when the ship turns.
The good news is, I think the housing correction has readjusted the market for the different types of housing. Many of those folks, and there are millions of them, that could previously have qualified for a high leverage mortgage to buy a stick built-house, are renters now. This has translated to fantastic sales results within our all-age portfolio in all regions of the country. As long as we remain focused on the overall value proposition this industry is based on, we expect this success to continue.
William Glascott
CFA Vice President Hometown America, LLC
312.604.7503 Office
312.604.3103 Fax
312.523.7584 Cell
The manufactured home industry is able to offer individuals and families an alternative affordable housing option during an economic transition.
Manufactured home communities offer an atmosphere and amenities that a typical apartment complex does not have. These include homes with a larger living area than a typical 2 bedroom apartment unit, individual yards in which pets and children can play safely, and a similar neighborhood atmosphere to that of a single-family subdivision.
The RHP Properties portfolio (70 communities, 15 states) continues to experience an increase in occupancy due to our strong hands -on management approach during these tough economic times.
Joshua Mermell
Director of Acquisitions RHP Properties, Inc
248.626.0737
Many owners have indicated that one of the biggest challenges of owning MHCs is having to carry notes of community-owned homes on the balance sheet. With the lack of chattel/manufactured home financing, how are you dealing with home financing issues?
As a company, we recognized years ago that we could not “get around” the necessity of financing homes in our communities. Our business model necessitates the three critical components of our asset class: retail sales of homes, retail financing of homes and quality communities in which to place those homes all for the purpose of creating the value proposition for the customer. We purchased a finance company with an on-going book of business and solid income stream, and expanded that company’s ability to grow and service our buyers. This approach keeps our balance sheet on the properties side focused on the traditional method of valuing properties which is the Net Operating Income tied to the real estate and not blurred by the necessity to evaluate the “home inventory”, however it is represented on the balance sheet.
James A. Reitzner
President & Director Asset Development Group, Inc
414.507.8057
jim.reitzner@assetdevelopment.com
We’re doing it ourselves. You are correct though that this is a big challenge as the capital requirement associated with home sales has increased. It has worked out for us as we’ve been able to manage delinquencies and turnover because we’re in the communities every day. From a capital preservation standpoint, it has worked out as we’re well capitalized, long term investors with the critical mass that supplies geographic and demographic diversity in our loan portfolio.
We do have good relationships with the national lenders that are still out there lending and work to establish partnerships with regional and local banks when possible. We are also always looking at creative ways to add liquidity to this market through industry initiatives and working with national organizations like the MHI. I think as investors come back to the market for asset backed securities (with help from Uncle Sam) and we as an industry can demonstrate transparent and stable loan performance, more chattel financing sources will surface. However, that means that we need to be very disciplined in our lending practices and underwriting so that we ensure these notes are marketable assets when that time does come.
William Glascott
CFA Vice President Hometown America, LLC
312.604.7503 Office
312.604.3103 Fax
312.523.7584 Cell
Tags: Appraisal, banking, Banks, Broker, Brokers, CAP Rates, capital marketplace, capitalization, Commercial, commercial banks, Commercial Real Estate, conduit loans, debt coverage, debt service coverage, Economics, Economy, fannie mae, individual properties, life insurance companies, life insurance company, loan industry, manufactured home communities, News, Office, PGP Valuation, Portland, Property, rate loan program, variable rate loan, Washington