Retail News Blog

On April 15th, we posted an article that described some of the financial difficulties that Walgreens is experiencing, and how this company is retooling to ensure long-term sustainability given current economic conditions. The recent struggles with this company along with scarcity of loan dollars and decreased market demand for all triple net properties are causing cap rates to increase for Walgreens, which have tended to set the low watermark for retail cap rates over the past few years.

A lot of investors steered clear of this passive investment due to the lack of rent growth, the above market rents associated with these built-to-suit projects and the low going in cap rates. Additionally, the values for this asset class are directly impacted by cap rate trends; there is no opportunity to offset increasing cap rates with rent growth because the contract rent is typically flat anywhere from 60 to 75 years. An investor that purchased a Walgreens at a 5.75% cap rate should know that there is a good chance the property has declined in value in excess of 20% (assuming 7% & up cap rates).

The following analysis is a basic overview of how our company recently estimated the applicable cap rate for a Walgreens property in eastern Oregon.

Analysis

As will be discussed shortly in the National Investor Survey, capitalization rate have jumped recently. This is notably true for asking rates of Walgreens. The Seattle-based senior vice president of CB Richard Ellis’ net-leased group, Jeffery Thomas, was recently reported in February 2009 as saying that because debt markets have become increasingly unstable since the fall of 2007, there has been a significant increase in the number of Walgreens marketed at above 7%. He feels that the ones currently marketed below 7% are stagnating and will soon be re-priced at more realistic levels. This is noted in the following Current Listings Cap Rate Summation Table, where Comparable 6 was just recently re-marketed at a 7% capitalization rate, up from 6.75 in March, 2009. Finally, Jeffery Thomas was quoted as saying that “We fully expect to see the Walgreens’ average asking cap rate reach 8% at some point in 2009.”

The following table summarizes six current listings of Walgreens along the West Coast, with the majority of them located in the Pacific Northwest.

All three of the listings in Oregon have listing capitalization rates ranging from 7.2% to 7.5%. The one Idaho listing is being offered at a capitalization rate of 7.3%. The lowest capitalization rate (7%) is for the California listing, and it is noted that it was being offered at a 6.75% capitalization rate as recently as the end of March 2009. Noting that these are listings in a buyers market, they are likely slightly low to good indicators for the subject.

The following table presents the capitalization rate conclusion by the market extraction method.

Band of Investments Technique – Because most properties are purchased with debt and equity capital, the overall capitalization rate must satisfy the market return requirements of both investment positions. Lenders must anticipate receiving a competitive interest rate commensurate with the perceived risk of the investment or they will not make funds available. Lenders also require that the principal amount of the loan be repaid through period amortization payments. Similarly, equity investors must anticipate receiving a competitive equity cash return commensurate with the perceived risk or they will invest their funds elsewhere.

 To analyze the capitalization rate from a financial position, the Band of Investments Technique is used. Available financing information from lenders and the sales comparables indicates the following terms:

Equity dividend rates vary depending upon motivations of buyers and financing terms. Although investors have been accepting meager equity dividends in recent years as low as 4% for this property type, moving forward opportunistic buyers will be most active and will require higher cash-on-cash returns. This factor is somewhat tempered by the low returns being provided by alternative investment vehicles (stock market, bonds, etc). The previous terms and an appropriate equity dividend rate are used in the Band of Investments calculations, which are presented in the following chart.

National Survey – The investor pool for the subject property includes national, regional and local investors. While all three groups place emphasis on local cap rates, regional and national investors would also strongly consider national cap rate trends due to the potential to invest in other regions that are offering higher rates of return. The following table summarizes national cap rate trends for net-leased properties.  

The preceding table clearly shows that cap rates slowly trended upwards through the end of 2007 and the first three quarters of 2008. The rate of increase sharply escalated in the fourth quarter of 2008 when it increased by 20 basis points. The increase in the most recent quarter was even more pronounced when it jumped by 73 basis points. The year to year increase was nearly a full percentage point at 95 basis points.

Retail properties in the Oregon marketplace have consistently been trading at slightly lower effective cap rates compared to the national averages. The region’s resilience to the changing national real estate market is commendable; however, the sweeping change in the mindset of investors has caught up here as well. Due to the substantially reduced transaction volume (down as much as 75% in 2008), it is rather unclear when the inflection point occurred; nonetheless, local cap rates have bottomed out and are on the rise. Pinpointing the applicable cap rate for the subject using national survey data is somewhat subjective. The most reasonable cap rate that can be derived from this analysis is presented in the following table. 

Capitalization Rate Conclusion – For investments of the subject’s general size and price, and when sales activity is brisk with relative market stability, the Market Extraction Method is most often relied upon by buyers and sellers to develop cap rate decisions. However, recent events indicate rapid and profound shifts in the financial environment and the economy on local, national and global levels. The other two approaches developed have varying limitations, but generally support the upward shift in capitalization rates. Taking all these factors into consideration, the following table summarizes the various capitalization rate indicators and provides the final capitalization rate conclusion.